This article builds on the foundational concepts discussed in our earlier article, “Shared Facilities Agreements: When, Why, and How to Utilize an SFA for Co-Located Energy Projects,” which focused on the operational and structural foundations of shared facilities agreements (SFAs). This follow-up article focuses on the critical items lenders, investors, and other financing parties will look for in SFAs and discusses the set of financing party protections that may be incorporated to make a co-located project financeable.
Financing Party Protections
Financing parties will commonly request that specific protections are included in the SFA. The following are some key provisions that may be included to protect financing party interests:
1. Collateral Assignment and Assignment of Undivided Interests
One of the core financing party requirements is to include language to ensure each party to the SFA has the ability to make a collateral assignment of the SFA and its undivided partial interest in the shared facilities. A party’s ability to collaterally assign the SFA and its undivided interest in the shared facilities can often be limited by the agreement’s general assignment restrictions. For this reason, it is important to include an express carve-out for collateral assignments to financing parties.
One nuance that may be overlooked is confirming that a financing party expressly has the right to foreclose on the undivided interest. As discussed further below, financing parties often want the ability to cure any breaches of the party being financed (on such party’s behalf). Without the right to foreclose on the collateral assignment of the undivided interest, the financing party may not be able to fully exercise such step-in and cure rights.
→ Additionally, parties should make sure to review the scope of the SFA to confirm the financing party’s collateral is accurately described. For example, a financing party might have an expectation that the entire project substation is included, but the agreement might include only specific equipment within the substation.
2. Obligation of Counterparties to Execute Financing Party Documents
Parties often need the cooperation of their SFA counterparties during financing to obtain necessary agreements and consents. To proactively require this cooperation, language in the SFA may be included to require that each nonassigning party promptly execute and deliver any required consents, estoppels, certificates, and other documentation to the financing parties as may reasonably be required.
In return, a non-assigning party may protect itself from unlimited exposure under this obligation by including some common guardrails. One common protection is to require that any terms in the documents requested by the financing parties not materially affect the non-assigning party’s rights or obligations under the SFA. Additionally, the assigning party may be required to reimburse each non-assigning party for expenses incurred in connection with providing the documents requested by the financing party.
3. Notice, Cure, and Step-In Rights
Perhaps the most operationally significant lender protection is the right of financing parties to receive notice of defaults under the SFA, to cure defaults, and to exercise step-in rights before any non-defaulting party is permitted to exercise remedies. An SFA should generally include language that recognizes a financing party’s right to be notified of any breach or default under the agreement, to be allowed the right to cure (including with reasonable extended cure periods), and to exercise any step-in and cure rights prior to any other party exercising remedies provided under the SFA.
Financing parties may also require that notice and cure provisions in the SFA mirror the language in the underlying financing documents and that the SFA clearly include a requirement for the non-defaulting party to notify the financing parties when it is aware a default has occurred. Without any notification obligation, financing parties would need to rely on the party that is in default to notify them of such. If the defaulting party is also the shared facilities manager, financing parties may also seek the right to remove and replace the shared facilities manager in connection with their exercise of remedies.
Equally important is the right to foreclose without triggering default under the SFA or otherwise providing a termination right to any party.
→ Step-in rights are some of the most commonly negotiated terms of an SFA. The parties should make sure to distinguish step-in rights where the defaulting party is the shared facilities manager and provide a mechanism for the parties to replace the shared facilities manager in an event of default.
4. Extended Cure Period
Another common protection for financing parties relates to the interaction between defaults and the remedy of physical disconnection from the shared facilities. Disconnection from shared infrastructure can have a significant impact from a project standpoint, so financing parties should have adequate time to step in and cure before that remedy becomes available.
For payment defaults, a party’s failure to make a required payment should not result in an event of default until the expiration of the cure period, which should be expressly subject to any applicable extended cure period provided to a financing party under the agreement. For defaults other than non-payment, the SFA should make clear that the shared facilities manager cannot disconnect a party’s facilities until all financing party cure periods have run.
5. Confidentiality Carve-Out for Financing Parties
While not a standalone provision, it is often critical to review and revise any confidentiality provisions as necessary to ensure the parties can share information with financing parties, actual and potential bidders for and purchasers of direct or indirect interests in the party’s respective project (including direct or indirect interests in the equity interests of the party or its affiliate), and credit rating agencies, provided that the applicable recipient has agreed to maintain the confidentiality of such information.
Other Common Provisions
Along with the detailed financing party protection provisions discussed above, financing parties will review the SFA to confirm the foundational structure of the co-location arrangement. The critical items financing parties will likely look for include the following:
A financing party will look to confirm that each party’s ownership interest in the shared facilities is structured as a tenancy-in-common rather than as a partnership or joint venture. This distinction matters, as a recharacterization of the arrangement as a partnership could potentially affect the financeability of the project, particularly for tax equity investors, and can have significant consequences under partnership tax rules.
Each party should retain an undivided interest in the shared facilities according to its proportionate share as a tenant-in-common, and the agreement should expressly state that nothing contained in it will be deemed to constitute the creation of a partnership or joint venture among the parties or to constitute the parties as partners or joint venturers of one another.
2. Waiver of Partition
A financing party’s collateral interest is only as secure as the underlying assets. If any party could seek partition of the shared facilities, the shared infrastructure that all co-located projects depend on could be dismantled. Thus, financing parties will look for language providing that each party waives any and all rights to seek partition or any other type of division of the shared facilities, and that the parties agree they will not participate in or permit any revocation, termination, or amendment of that waiver without the prior written consent of the other parties and their financing parties. This is one of the most important protections financing parties should obtain in an SFA.
3. Permitted Liens
Financing parties must also confirm that the SFA’s lien restrictions are structured to accommodate their security interests. A financing party may seek to confirm that no party may, directly or indirectly, create, incur, or permit to exist any lien other than permitted liens on the right, title, or undivided interest of the other parties in the shared facilities, and similarly that no party may permit any lien other than permitted liens on its own interest in the shared facilities. Financing parties should also confirm that their own security interests are included in the definition of permitted liens and that the collateral assignment structure works in concert with those restrictions.
Conclusion
Taken together, these provisions form the core of a financeable shared facilities agreement. As co-located energy and data center projects become more common and more complex, careful attention to each of these items during SFA negotiation will be essential for any party seeking to finance a co-located project.
→ As mentioned in our first article, there is not a “one size fits all” approach to structuring SFAs, so it is important to work with counsel and financing parties early to identify potential financing party requirements in order to avoid common delays in project financing.
Contact Us
For more information on financing considerations for shared facilities agreements or co-located energy projects, please contact Jeff Vercauteren, Brittney Beetcher, or your Husch Blackwell attorney.